September 14, 2023
Troy D. Smith
“Who Is It That ‘Weaponized the Justice System’?”
I want to open this week by acknowledging John Gottlied’s
references to my column last week. I can honestly say the same things about his
writings that he said about mine: I often disagree (sometimes vehemently), I
agree more often than people might expect, and I eagerly await each week’s new
installment.
Now on to this week’s topic.
Sometimes my irony barometer is strained to the point of
breaking. Oddly enough, it usually occurs as a result of Trump or his
followers. Take, for instance, this refrain we are constantly hearing nowadays:
“Joe Biden is weaponizing the Justice Department by going after his political
enemies!” Or this nugget: “We have a two-tiered justice system, with
conservatives on the bottom being persecuted!”
Let’s take that second one first. We DO have a two-tiered
legal system, all right. What if Trump really had won in 2020 (instead of just
pretending to), and those January 6 protesters had been Black Lives Matter
activists? Do you think they would have all gone home and slept in their own
beds that night? How many do you think would have never gone home at all? I
think we all know it would almost certainly have been more than the one rioter
who was killed in the real attack. This, despite the fact that all the numbers
show that the vast majority of terrorist attacks in this country since 9/11 have
been perpetrated by far-right extremists.
But that first one, about “weaponizing the Justice
Department,” that is a real doozy. It was Donald Trump who had, as one of his
main campaign slogans in 2016, “Lock her up!” This was over Hillary Clinton’s
alleged carelessness with classified documents online, when Trump illegally
kept more sensitive documents (involving, among other things, nuclear secrets)
in his pool-house and bathroom. It was Donald Trump whose two Senate-confirmed
attorneys-general, both of them in ideological lockstep with him, wound up
losing their jobs because they drew a line at how far they were willing to
abuse their offices at his command. In fact, just 26 days before the 2020
election, Trump called for Bill Barr to indict Joe Biden for the “greatest
crime in history,” allegedly “perpetrating the Russia hoax.” Heck, just nine
months ago Trump said that “A Massive Fraud of this type and magnitude allows
for the termination of all rules, regulations, and articles, even those found
in the Constitution.”
Before you think I am practicing the sort of what-aboutism I
criticize in others, allow me explain the difference. Hillary Clinton did not
get locked up, and Joe Biden did not get indicted, for one simple reason. There
was no evidence. It was not political -it was Republican officials who declined
to do what Trump wanted, for the simple reason they could not win in court with
nothing more than accusations. Everything that Donald Trump and his cronies
have been indicted for, and are being tried for, is backed up by massive
amounts of evidence. This is further reinforced by the fact that, as we learned
last week, the Georgia grand jury also recommended indictments for Lindsay
Graham, Mike Flynn, and several others (including both former Republican
senators from Georgia). If the whole thing was a political hit job, a
Republican as prominent as Lindsay Graham would surely have been getting his
mug shot taken -but the D.A. declined to indict those individuals because there
wasn’t as much clear evidence against them in this case.
To decline to prosecute someone with this much evidence of
criminality, just because of an election… THAT would be the miscarriage of
justice. Laws matter.
--Troy D.
Smith, a White County native, is a novelist and a history professor at
Tennessee Tech. His words do not necessarily represent TTU.
Buy the book A Liberal Dose: Communiques from the Holler by Troy D. Smith HERE
You can find all previous entries in this weekly column HERE
A list of other historical essays that have appeared on this blog can be found HERE
Author's website: www.troyduanesmith.com
The author's historical lectures on youtube can be found HERE
No comments:
Post a Comment