April 30, 2026
You can find all previous entries in this weekly column HERE
A list of other historical essays that have appeared on this blog can be found HERE
Author's website: www.troyduanesmith.com
April 30, 2026
You can find all previous entries in this weekly column HERE
A list of other historical essays that have appeared on this blog can be found HERE
Author's website: www.troyduanesmith.com
Troy D. Smith was born in the Upper Cumberland region of Tennessee in 1968. He writes in a variety of genres, achieving his earliest successes with westerns -his first published short story appeared in 1995 in Louis L'Amour Western Magazine, and he won the Spur Award in 2001 for the novel Bound for the Promise-Land and in 2017 for the short story "Odell's Bones" (being a finalist on two other occasions.) He received his PhD in history from the University of Illinois, and is currently a history professor at Tennessee Tech.
I posted this on May 26, right after the end of the meeting when the TNDP Executive Committee, on which I served, voted to remove our former Treasurer from the EC.
Troy D. Smith was born in the Upper Cumberland region of Tennessee in 1968. He writes in a variety of genres, achieving his earliest successes with westerns -his first published short story appeared in 1995 in Louis L'Amour Western Magazine, and he won the Spur Award in 2001 for the novel Bound for the Promise-Land and in 2017 for the short story "Odell's Bones" (being a finalist on two other occasions.) He received his PhD in history from the University of Illinois, and is currently a history professor at Tennessee Tech.
A Liberal Dose April 24, 2026
“Too Fast to Be
Furious: The Temperamental Drift”
Troy D. Smith
Historians are trained to argue, as are academics in
general. We are trained in doing deep research and finding sources, facts, perspectives,
root causes, repercussions, and context in relation to other aspects of
history. Then other historians do the same thing, in an effort to present a
counter-narrative, and “discourse” is created. I regard this process as an
ongoing conversation about historical topics, with each new generation of
historians (and their arguments) building on what came before, bringing us
closer to that elusive thing called “truth” -which, like Zeno’s paradox about
continually halving the distance between one object and another, can only be
approached but never fully reached. Although this process can be very dry, it
can also be very passionate and sometimes a little ugly (both in print and in
person). I like to define academic writing as writing something that will only be
read by ten people who hate you. Nonetheless, that discourse is expected to
take place with professionalism.
Political writing, especially opinion pieces, are also
arguments. It is usually not just an expression of some free-standing opinion
(like Andy Rooney’s pieces used to be on Sixty Minutes). It is most frequently
an effort to be persuasive to an audience and inspire them to tackle some issue
or effect some political change that the author finds (in their opinion) very
important. It is even more susceptible to becoming passionate or heated than
are interpretations of history. And that is expected. It is nearly impossible
to persuade anybody to do anything without first emphasizing the stakes.
Ideally, though, when two citizens with opposing views express them to one
another, even heatedly, they do so within certain parameters of civil behavior,
and with the viewpoint that their opponent loves their country as much as they
do, they just disagree on how best to express it. This has been true since
disagreements arose between Jefferson and Hamilton when the ink was barely dry
on the Constitution.
Boy, those were the days.
It’s been a long time
since civility or professionalism showed their heads on the public scene.
Pre-existing groups, such as political parties, have tended to cluster at
extremes -extremes in policy, and extremes in debating it. Talking politics
-even with people on your own side! -leads some individuals to go from 0 to 100
in a split-second where aggression is concerned. This has led not only to crass
rhetoric but to violence, and many factors have contributed to that situation.
But it keeps getting worse.
I have been warning of that in this newspaper throughout the
decade of the 2020s, in columns with titles like “Some of Y’all Need to Calm
Down and Take a Breath” (June 20, 2025). It has become practically expected,
and definitely not out of the ordinary, for a political columnist to be
threatened with physical injury. Of late, I’ve been receiving metaphysical
threats from people on my own side who disagree with me on some things, as have
some of the conservative-leaning columnists in this paper in the past. That
phenomenon has the same symptoms as if it were coming from the other side:
people jumping straight to anger and outrage, then on to harsh attacks, without
waiting to find out the facts. Facts themselves seem to have gone out of style.
Fury has become the driver for what passes for discourse these days.
Of course, there is very much a need for righteous anger
sometimes. But even that needs to be directed to the right sources, and
DIRECTED period, not like a shotgun blast. People who wish to effect change must
let even their anger be strategic. Anger without focus makes one easily misled
and misdirected, and easily herded into traps. I’m not singing kumbaya, I’m
still going to argue passionately for what I believe in -I’m saying don’t be
Sonny Corleone. Stop and think, don’t just react.
The times are dangerous enough already.
--Troy D. Smith
is a novelist and a history professor at Tennessee Tech University. His words
do not necessarily represent TTU, nor are they connected in any way with his
job- they are his own opinions on matters of public concern, and an expression
of his First Amendment freedom of speech.
Buy the book A Liberal Dose: Communiques from the Holler by Troy D. Smith HERE
You can find all previous entries in this weekly column HERE
A list of other historical essays that have appeared on this blog can be found HERE
Author's website: www.troyduanesmith.com
Troy D. Smith was born in the Upper Cumberland region of Tennessee in 1968. He writes in a variety of genres, achieving his earliest successes with westerns -his first published short story appeared in 1995 in Louis L'Amour Western Magazine, and he won the Spur Award in 2001 for the novel Bound for the Promise-Land and in 2017 for the short story "Odell's Bones" (being a finalist on two other occasions.) He received his PhD in history from the University of Illinois, and is currently a history professor at Tennessee Tech.
A Liberal Dose
Unsilenced and Back
in the Saddle
Troy D. Smith
March 27, 2026
This piece represents my return to sharing political
commentary -from a left perspective and with historical context -after a
six-month hiatus due to numerous death threats I received in the days after
Charlie Kirk’s assassination (despite the fact I had never commented on that
subject). Since this is, in effect, a fresh start, and since it may appear in
news outlets outside my hometown, I thought it might be appropriate to re-introduce
myself before getting into the political opinion part.
My name is Troy Smith. I was born and raised in White
County, in the Upper Cumberland region of Tennessee -a region my family has
lived in for well over two hundred years. I am a history professor at Tennessee
Tech University. My specialties include indigenous studies, the history of
race, and the American South. I am from a rural blue-collar background and
spent more than twenty years doing janitorial work before becoming an academic.
I’ve lived other places -including a couple of years doing mission work with
Haitian immigrants in the Miami and New York City areas, and six years getting
my Ph.D. at the University of Illinois -but Tennessee is my home, and I love
it. I am also an author of fiction,
mostly westerns. My first published work appeared thirty years ago in Louis
L’Amour Western Magazine, and I’ve won a couple of Spur awards from Western
Writers of America. Finally, I am politically active -serving my district on
the Tennessee Democratic Party executive committee. The words and thoughts in
my column are my own, though, and in no way officially represent the TNDP or
TTU.
That whole paragraph was meant to drive home the fact that,
though I work at a university, my background is not one of elite privilege but
as one of Tennessee’s working poor -and I have never let go of that experience.
I know very well what it feels like to be from rural poverty, and to be looked
down on for it on a personal level while seeing my state, especially the
country and small-town parts of it, repeatedly taken advantage of, taken for
granted, put down, and being flat-out cheated by con artists and fat cats
looking to make a fast buck off of us. And I’m tired of it, as I bet you are. So
I have spoken up, and continue speaking up, despite the efforts of those who
would like to keep voices like yours and mine silent. Exercising the right to
speak up is the very essence of what it means to be American, and so is the
refusal to be denied that basic, natural right.
I am speaking up about the fact that voters in this state
-especially in the rural counties -have been sold a bill of goods comprised of
empty promises in order to get their vote. We were promised that prices would
go down “on day one”, but they keep going up and up. We were promised the full
release of the Epstein files, and the protection of the innocent and vulnerable
-but this administration has fought tooth-and-nail every step of the way to
keep that information out of our hands, and have outright admitted they are
doing so to protect their billionaire friends. We were promised no wars, yet
they just started one without having even the vaguest plan of how to win it.
The federal government, and the Republican-controlled government in this state,
keep setting us at each other’s throats to distract us from the fact they are
picking our pockets. Don’t forget the governor’s private school voucher plan,
that is draining money from rural school systems and hardworking teachers while
benefitting his wealthy friends.
They think because we are rural we are stupid and easily
controlled. But people are waking up to the fact that the longer Republicans
are in charge the worse things get.
Speak up with me, neighbors.
Buy the book A Liberal Dose: Communiques from the Holler by Troy D. Smith HERE
You can find all previous entries in this weekly column HERE
A list of other historical essays that have appeared on this blog can be found HERE
Author's website: www.troyduanesmith.com
Troy D. Smith was born in the Upper Cumberland region of Tennessee in 1968. He writes in a variety of genres, achieving his earliest successes with westerns -his first published short story appeared in 1995 in Louis L'Amour Western Magazine, and he won the Spur Award in 2001 for the novel Bound for the Promise-Land and in 2017 for the short story "Odell's Bones" (being a finalist on two other occasions.) He received his PhD in history from the University of Illinois, and is currently a history professor at Tennessee Tech.
A LIBERAL DOSE, January 7, 2026
"Have You No Sense of Decency?"
Troy D. Smith
Five years ago.
Five years ago saw the Capital stormed for the first time since the War of 1812. Like the rest of the world, I sat and watched in horror as MAGA faithful, spurred on by Donald Trump, surged into the building and viciously assaulted police officers, wandered the halls calling out for Nancy Pelosi and other Democratic leaders, erected a scaffold to hang the Vice-President for his refusal to obey Trump's wish for him to refuse to certify the results of the election, thereby setting the stage for a fake elector scheme to subvert the outcome of a free and fair election. Watch the body cam footage of the Capital police... it's horrifying. And the lame-duck president was sitting in the White House watching it on television and cheering the rioters instead of calling for them to stop, or ordering forces in to quell them, and saying that maybe his VP deserved to be lynched anyway. Anyone with the slightest grasp on history recognized this as a potential Reichstag moment -that Trump was stalling, hoping the crowd would get even more violent so that when he finally did call in troops he could declare martial law and forcibly stay in power. Heck, as I said at the time, you don't even have to know history- you just have to have paid attention to Star Wars. It was an attempted insurrection, and on that day everyone knew it, no matter how hard they now try to retcon the events and their own reactions to it.
It was one of the worst days in U.S. history.
Many of us took consolation in the fact it didn't work, and that the shear ignominy of it would be a stake in the orange Nosferatu's heart. Many of us were heartened when Congress voted to impeach him even though he only had a couple of weeks in office; a conviction in such an impeachment would mean he would never be able to run for any public office again, and America would have successfully dodged a fascist bullet. Of course, Senate Republicans -led by Mitch McConnell, whose wife Elaine Chao served as Transportation Secretary and had been the object of ethnic slurs by the president, and who resigned from her position in protest after the riot. So McConnell knew how dangerous a returned Trump would be. But he, and most other Republican Senators, refused to convict the president despite overwhelming evidence -to appease Trump's voters and keep their loyalty in the midterms. They gambled that Trump's political career was over. Despite that, Americans like me breathed a sigh of relief. Biden was successfully installed and, we hoped, things could return to some semblance of normal.
Two or three weeks later I was approached by an officer of my home county's Democratic Party, who had in turn been approached by the editor of my hometown paper. They needed a leftwing contributor to balance their opinion page -at that time they had two conservative columnists, both of them very far to the right. They could find no volunteers, and I was told there was some trepidation over death threats for people publicly espousing a liberal perspective in a town that had gone almost 80% for Trump in the recent election. And thus I was able to add "newspaper columnist" to my resume. For almost five years I wrote that weekly column, which I titled "A Liberal Dose." To my surprise, a lot of people over those years told me how much the column meant to them and how often they agreed with me on things even if they were Republicans. My very favorite comment: "It's very rare to see a white person stand up for us Black folks in this town- and I have NEVER seen a white person stand up for Indians here." Despite that, even some of my conservative friends (including a couple whose opinions on such matters are based on their professional backgrounds) frequently expressed concern for my personal safety.
This is the first essay I've put up in over two months, since shortly after my newspaper column (and in fact the whole opinion page) was cancelled due to the high number of death threats I (and the staff, it sounded like) received in the week after Charlie Kirk's death. At the time, I said I was going to keep putting these things out on my blog, and I did a couple, but at one point it looked like a larger paper might be picking up my column, so I was waiting to see how that played out. However, more than one member of my family implored me not to do that, when there were already enough people in my hometown that apparently wanted to shoot me. I felt like I had to honor that, especially since they might also be endangered by my actions. If left to my own devices, I would have plunged ahead -I've always said I'm just smart enough to know when to shut up, and just dumb enough not to. I'm glad my family is here to help me take stock of such things. It is worth noting that my wife, who makes her living selling jewelry online, was kicked off of her main platform at around the same time for comments she made condemning Christian Nationalism on her own Facebook page, which has been a hit on our pocketbook, and in a world where professors were being fired around the country for expressing any opinions about Charlie Kirk, the possibility of that happening to me could cost us our mortgage and our health insurance (though thankfully, in one of the worst cases of such injustice, a judge just in the past day or two found in favor of the professor -also in Tennessee, though not my university -and he has his job back, plus $500,000).
But it is past time for me to speak out again, at least in this format if not in print. This despite the fact that -due to MAGA -I'm having to take extraordinary security and defense measures -but so are all of our neighboring countries, apparently.
I've seen a lot of confusion online about U.S. actions in Venezuela, due no doubt to how shocking it is. I mean, the U.S. has embarked on many imperialist ventures in its existence, but we almost always PRETEND like that's not what we're doing. There's an element of that here- the Trump administration has repeatedly stated that the goal is to cut off the fentanyl coming to the United States... despite the fact everyone knows Venezuela isn't where fentanyl enters the U.S. No, the shocking part is that Trump is saying the quiet part out loud. He is announcing now that it is all about Venezuela's oil, which we are going to take because, somehow, it BELONGS to us. And we are going to "run their country" until they get a leader we approve of. He also reiterated his goal to possess Greenland, hinting he might use military measures to do so -and people know now that they have to take any and all of his childish threats seriously, because no matter how stupid and undemocratic they sound, there is always a possibility he will carry them out. He also made totally-not-veiled threats against Mexico and Cuba.
In other words, there is a very real danger we may enter a shooting-war with Venezuela. And Mexico and Cuba, and potentially other Latin American countries. And, if we invade Greenland, we will be at war with all our NATO allies. This is not a joke, nor is it an exaggeration.
Observers correctly point to this as part of a return to "spheres of influence" diplomacy, which was the norm until WWII (and which helped LEAD to WWII, with appeasement of Hitler). As many have pointed out, it is eerily like the dividing up of the three major nations in the novel 1984. In essence, it seems like the plan is to divide the whole world among the U.S. (who would get the whole western hemisphere, including Greenland and Canada), Russia (who would get Europe and perhaps Eurasia), and China, who would get Asia. In this scenario, the three powers would be like, I suppose, the Axis on which the world turns (and I sure hope you get that reference, but if you're under a certain age -due to MAGA attacks on truthful teaching of history over the last decade -I can't count on it.) Looking at it in that framework, suddenly it all makes perfect sense -from Trump's touting of the Monroe (now apparently Don-roe, according to him) Doctrine and actions in Latin America, to his frequent statements coveting Canada and Greenland, to his unbelievable deference to Putin no matter what he does in his own "sphere." Our nation in currently led by people who don't even PRETEND to love democracy and freedom, or the Constitution, or anything other than money and raw power- for their own narrow group of cronies.
And meanwhile, here at home, the military is patrolling the streets of American cities. Democracy is being strangled. The very concepts of history, truth, and objective fact are being strangled. And masked secret police are arresting people without warrants and apparently now shooting them in the face for no reason other than being in the wrong place at the wrong time. I could go on and on, but the short version is: in almost every way, in one year's time, our country has been traveling at dizzying speed down the road of fascism, authoritarianism, and dictatorship.
Just like we kept telling people it would, but many were not listening because the cost of eggs had gone up.
On the day of the 2021 insurrection, out of curiosity, I got on Facebook and checked the timelines of my most conservative, pro-MAGA friends and acquaintances. Crickets. And I knew why: they were in shock like the rest of us, and were too deeply ashamed to say a word. Until a few days later, when they started making excuses and/or denying we had even seen what we saw that day. I checked their timelines yesterday, the 5th anniversary of the insurrection and just a few days after the attack on Venezuela- they were crowing and bragging about both things. I checked them today, after a full day of news about the murder of that poor woman by masked ICE agents in Minneapolis -a white woman, mind you, who from what I have heard so far might not have even been there protesting, she may have just been passing through and got stuck. Guess what? CRICKETS. Because they know. They know how wring this is, and they are ashamed of it, and scared to stick their heads up and be recognized as supporting it. Until tomorrow, or maybe the next day, when they will have gathered up their nerve and are once more vacillating between denying the obvious facts and gloating and crowing over it.
I am reminded of the words of then Secretary of State John Quincy Adams during the lead up to the 1820 Missouri Compromise, about Southern supporters of slavery: "They have betrayed the secrets of their soul." That is, despite all their talk about freedom and democracy, at the end of the day they loved their white supremacy. He added that if there were one thing the country OUGHT to be broken over, it was the cruel hypocrisy of slavery. Of course, you may not see that quote at the Smithsonian, where the Trump administration has complained they talk too much about "how bad" slavery was and they should just skip over it.
I am reminded also of the words of Thomas Paine in The Crisis, published in Philadelphia in December of 1776, when things were looking bleak for the Revolution -and which was read aloud to George Washington's troops right before they crossed the Delaware River:
These are the times that try men’s souls: The summer soldier and the sunshine patriot will, in this crisis, shrink from the service of his country; but he that stands it now, deserves the love and thanks of man and woman. Tyranny, like hell, is not easily conquered; yet we have this consolation with us, that the harder the conflict, the more glorious the triumph. What we obtain too cheap, we esteem too lightly: It is dearness only that gives every thing its value. Heaven knows how to set a proper price upon its goods; and it would be strange indeed, if so celestial an article as FREEDOM should not be highly rated.
These ARE the times that try our souls. Everything about our country, and its promise, and its potential though yet to be fulfilled, is being stripped away daily in real time before our very eyes. But this is NOT the time to shrink back. It is the time to stand up and be loud. It is time to speak out about where we stand; it is time to heap shame on the heads of these aggressors just as abolitionists did in the 19th century, all while telling our misled neighbors that THIS IS NOT WHAT THEY VOTED FOR. They voted for lower prices and no more wars. They were roped in by the illusory scam of a professional con artist who hungered for nothing but more money, public adulation, and raw unlimited (kinglike) power... and it's okay for those misled neighbors to admit it, and to now demand something better.
In the 1950s, Republican Senator Joseph McCarthy had America tied in knots, rife with paranoia and turning on one another. His mad accusations and actions seemed to amplify day-by-day, until some feared it would destroy the country. Until people started to stand up. Until CBS anchorman Edward R. Murrow aired exposes of McCarthyism, telling the American people, "We will not walk in fear, one of another. We will not be driven by fear into an age of unreason, if we dig deep in our history and our doctrine, and remember that we are not descended from fearful men." Until lawyer Joseph Welch said, on live television and to McCarthy's face, ""Have you no sense of decency, sir? At long last, have you left no sense of decency?" And America began to wake up.
Have you no sense of decency, sir? At long last, have you left no sense of decency? Well, the greater part of the American people, who do not support any of this behavior, do. Now it's time to wake up the rest of them.
I close with this official statement from the Tennessee Democratic Party, of which I am proud to serve on the executive committee- and never before prouder than today.
--Troy D. Smith is a novelist and a history professor at Tennessee Tech and serves on the executive committee of the Tennessee Democratic Party. His words do not necessarily represent TTU., nor are they connected in any way with his job- they are his own opinions on matters of public concern, and an expression of his First Amendment freedom of speech.
Buy the book A Liberal Dose: Communiques from the Holler by Troy D. Smith HERE
You can find all previous entries in this weekly column HERE
A list of other historical essays that have appeared on this blog can be found HERE
Author's website: www.troyduanesmith.com
Troy D. Smith was born in the Upper Cumberland region of Tennessee in 1968. He writes in a variety of genres, achieving his earliest successes with westerns -his first published short story appeared in 1995 in Louis L'Amour Western Magazine, and he won the Spur Award in 2001 for the novel Bound for the Promise-Land and in 2017 for the short story "Odell's Bones" (being a finalist on two other occasions.) He received his PhD in history from the University of Illinois, and is currently a history professor at Tennessee Tech.