A Liberal
Dose
March 9,
2023
Troy D.
Smith
“Let’s All
Find the Better Angels of Our Nature”
I want to begin this column by acknowledging John
Gottlied’s statement last week that, despite our many disagreements, he is
never attacking me personally because he believes I am a good man (and, in the
past, he’s said my heart is usually in the right place). I can say the exact
same thing about him. I recommended him for this column because I know he is a
man of principle who would never hold back from ardently criticizing my views
when he disagrees with them, without resorting to the nastiness that has become
so common in our public life today. I am grateful to the Expositor for publishing both our viewpoints, because I think it is
good for readers to see that two men, friends since childhood who love each
other as brothers and respect one another, can disagree over politics -and even
get mad sometimes -without losing sight of each other’s humanity. As I said,
that seems to have become a scarce commodity nowadays.
It shouldn’t be like that. It doesn’t have to be like
that.
I think frequently about the funeral of Democratic
senator Ted Kennedy, the “liberal lion”, in 2009. I was moved by the heartfelt
tears of Republican senator Orrin Hatch, one of Kennedy’s best friends. They
were not only from different parties, Hatch had campaigned his way into
Congress over thirty years earlier expressly on the platform of thwarting the
liberal policies of, specifically, Ted Kennedy. Yet they worked together on
important legislation through the years, and developed a powerful friendship
I think, too, of the presidential campaign of 1800.
Back then, whoever came in second in the election would serve as vice-president
to whoever won (what could go wrong?). In 1796 Thomas Jefferson had come in
second to John Adams. Jefferson and Adams had been close allies and friends
during the Revolution and for several years afterwards, but when our present
government was formed as a result of the Constitution the two men found
themselves increasingly at odds. By 1796 Jefferson and James Madison had formed
a political party, the Republicans -known to historians as the
Democratic-Republicans and reorganized in the mid-1820s as the Democratic
Party, so not to be confused with the modern Republican Party. Adams,
meanwhile, joined the Federalist Party formed by Alexander Hamilton.
Jefferson/Madison and Adams/Hamilton had very different ideas about what was
best for the country, which sometimes led to animosity.
This was especially true during the Adams-Jefferson administration,
as the two men went at each other sometimes viciously, with Jefferson running
against Adams again in 1800 and defeating him. To get by the “second-place gets
VP” rule, the Democratic-Republicans also ran another candidate, Aaron Burr
-all the party delegates were supposed to vote for both (each delegate got two
votes) but one was supposed to NOT list Burr, guaranteeing he would come in
right behind Jefferson if Jefferson won, and be his VP. But the delegates
apparently became confused, because Jefferson and Burr wound up tied (ahead of
Adams), which meant the election was sent to the House of Representatives to
decide. The House was evenly divided and no clear winner was evident there,
either. Hamilton stepped in and urged his party to throw their votes to
Jefferson. Despite their differences, Hamilton viewed Jefferson as a good and
honorable man, a “lover of liberty,” whereas he called Burr an “embryo Caesar”
who loved nothing but himself (Burr later killed Hamilton in a duel). When
Jefferson was inaugurated he sought to calm the acrimony of the campaign by
saying, famously, “We are all Republicans. We are all Federalists.” It took
another decade, but after Jefferson left office he and John Adams even renewed
their close friendship.
Here’s hoping our current season turns out more like
that, rather than take the turn things did in the 1850s/1860s. Let’s all return,
instead, to what Lincoln called “the better angels of our nature.”
--Troy D. Smith, a White County native, is a novelist and a
history professor at Tennessee Tech. His words do not necessarily represent
TTU.
You can find all previous entries in this weekly column HERE
A list of other historical essays that have appeared on this blog can be found HERE
Author's website: www.troyduanesmith.com
No comments:
Post a Comment